to

Ani-Gamers Podcast #036 – Experts of Fan Controversy

Topics: , ,

Featuring: Alex Leavitt, Chris Beveridge, Ed Chavez, Jennifer Fu, Clarissa Graffeo, and Ada Palmer

Yes, yes, I promised a review of Spice & Wolf for this episode, but Alex Leavitt has forced my hand by politely requesting this long-overdue recording. That's right, get ready for ANGRY ARGUMENTS, because this is Experts of Fan Controversy (Anime Boston 2011), in which anime fandom "experts" face off on major issues of the day, including piracy and translation accuracy! OK, let's be honest here: there isn't actually much controversy or anger in this panel, but it certainly has lots of very useful insights into the workings of the anime industry and fandom. Plus it's got points. And who doesn't love points?

Show notes and links are coming soon, and cross your fingers for that Spice & Wolf episode next time!

DIRECT DOWNLOAD - RSS Feed - iTunes - Send us Feedback! - More episodes 
 
(Runtime: 1 hour, 22 minutes)

Anime Boston 2011: Day 3 Diary

Topics: ,
I loved this view of a single dude valiantly playing an arcade machine in the corner of the video game room

After two days of hectic panel coverage, Sunday was surprisingly laid-back. There were far fewer attendees milling about in many of the hallways near the panel rooms, so navigation was considerably easier than it was on Friday and Saturday. Additionally, there weren't a ton of panels I wanted to cover, so I had a chance to check out a lot of the other traditional areas of the con.

My first panel experience of the day, however, was the Akira Kurosawa panel, run by so-called "Dungeon Master Jim." It was the first presentation I saw from this prolific Anime Boston panelist, and I was a little underwhelmed. There were no visual aids (surprising for a panel about as visual a medium as cinema) and Jim seemed to have only seen the "big" Kurosawa films, as the audience ended up suggesting films for him to check out. I'm not a Kurosawa buff myself, but a tip for anyone running a panel about a director: Do your best to watch literally everything they've ever worked on. Your panel isn't worth anyone's time unless you have a thorough understanding of the topic at hand.

The video game room (an area I usually neglect due to all my press work) was massive, leading to amusing wide spaces between the different play areas (see this post's image). I managed to sneak in a game of Tatsunoko vs. Capcom, as I've never gotten a chance to play it, though I got handily beaten by a guy who had just started playing today!

Then it was off to Sam Kusek, Ken Haley, and Mike Ferreira's "From East to West: the Superheroes of Japan & America." Like Sam's previous panel ("Super-Flat"), it was very fast-paced, to-the-point, and well researched, and the three hosts bounced off each other well. Plus, I learned a lot about the history and influences of Japanese tokusatsu (special effects) shows, as well as some classic American comics like Superman and Captain America, all of which are topics I am woefully uneducated on.

Afterward I checked out the Dealer's Room again, this time with Sam and his buddies. After vacillating over the purchase of some old-school imported Japanese magazines at the Comicopia booth, I ended up buying a $2 Japanese children's book "Heidi, Girl of the Alps," featuring anime-style art but apparently having nothing to do with the Isao Takahata anime TV series of the same name. Naturally, this was from the same dealer (Mugen Toys) who sold me the Kosaku Shima books the day before! Then Sam, his friends, and I grabbed some great Asian food at a nearby Teriyaki restaurant, and I headed back to the hotel to catch our bus back to RPI.

My experience at Anime Boston was honestly one of the better ones I've ever had at a con, despite a few frustrating setbacks along the way. The wide range of panels and panelists opened up some great avenues of discussion, and I was able to cram in a wide breadth of events (panels and otherwise) in my time at the con. I'll write more about my specific high and low points in my upcoming con report, but let's just say that my long-awaited reunion with the city of Boston and its resident anime con was a very positive one.



Click here for more of our Anime Boston 2011 coverage

Anime Boston 2011: Day 2 Diary

Topics: ,
GunDUMB

Day 2 of Anime Boston was just as hectic as the first, as I had scheduled myself for way more panels than I could actually get to. But despite frantically running around the con all day, I managed to sit down for a couple of really stand-out presentations.

"The Family That Geeks Together Keeps Together" was scheduled in a tiny little panel room and hosted by the Hoffmans (father Constantine, mother Jennifer, and son Greg), a family of geeks trying to spread the word on geeky parenthood and childhood at conventions. At times the panel boiled down to recommendations for getting parents into anime, but when the audience started discussing family dynamics and geekdom in depth, bouncing off of each other, it turned into a really enlightening panel.

I stopped in for a bit at Anime World Order's Gerald and Clarissa's "Tezuka 101," which was an appropriately introductory panel that followed much of the information provided in Helen McCarthy's excellent The Art of Osamu Tezuka: God of Manga. There wasn't really anything for an amateur Tezuka scholar like myself to learn, but it was quite in-depth for people new to the artist.

"It's a Rumic World," a presumably informative panel about Rumiko Takahashi, was basically just a fan-gushing session, not too appropriate for people trying to learn about the prolific manga artist. Soon after, I checked out "The State of the Industry," which featured ONLY Adam and Rojas from FUNimation. In fact, the Anime Boston-designated moderator never showed up, so Gia Manry (of Anime News Network) served as moderator for what ended up being a pregame FUNimation panel, albeit with more industry insight and less blatant marketing. (I recorded the whole thing, and may post it up.)

One of the highlights of my day was "Remembering Satoshi Kon," Daryl Surat's panel about the late director, which I served as co-panelist on. We packed the room, and after some tripping over each other's feet, we developed a pretty good rapport.

Sam Kusek and Eric Shorey ran a fantastic panel called "'What is Super-Flat': Where Anime fits in Post-Modern Culture," which was a very academic look at post-modernism with nods to Japanese artists like Murakami and anime like Paranoia Agent. I'm considering doing a write-up of the panel, as it brought up a lot of interesting ideas.

Gerald Rathkolb's "The Sane Fan's Guide to Mecha Anime" was a pretty thorough yet basic introduction to mecha, though he occasionally lapsed into more in-depth stuff before reeling it back. Proving his point that mecha fans can be totally obnoxious, some guys in Legend of the Galactic Heroes costumes ran into the room and screamed "Sig Zeon!" (a reference to original Gundam).

After grabbing a quick dinner, I headed over to the absurd clipshow that is Anime Hell, hosted by Mike Toole, Daryl Surat, and Mike Horne. It featured a lot of Daryl's clips from his Genericon presentation of "The Panel of Doom," so I had already seen a lot of it, and Daryl's laptop had a bunch of technical problems, but it was still a hilarious night.

And during a quick trip to the dealer's room, I managed to find some Kodansha Bilingual Comics Editions of volumes 1, 2, and 3 of business manga Section Chief Kosaku Shima, which I bought for $2 each at the Mugen Toys booth! Quite a find, apparently, though I didn't realize just how rare they were when I bought them.



Click here for more of our Anime Boston 2011 coverage

Anime Boston 2011: Day 1 Diary [EDIT 1]

Topics: ,
Attendees waiting in the registration hallway

NOTE: This post was written last night, but since my hotel room doesn't have Internet, I had to wait till the morning to post it!

As with most first days of anime cons, today has been a complete whirlwind. I woke up at 4:30am to catch an early bus with the RSFA so that we would be on the show floor at the Hynes Convention Center in Boston by noon. Everything basically went off without a hitch, but the early morning departure meant no chance for a real breakfast, and my hectic schedule made it hard to find time to grab anything.

Once I had myself sort of settled, I decided to check in on the "Tokyo 'Nonexistant Youth' Bill and How It Affects You" panel, which was unfortunately run by what looked like a very nervous college student (EDIT: I am told by commenters that he actually has a very bad stutter in general) and filled with flimsy equivalences between the new bill and perceived future censorship.

"Fanthropologies," a panel run by the indomitable Charles Dunbar and featuring Alex Leavitt and Jennifer Fu as guests, was ostensibly about the study of fandom, both in terms of anime and other media, but it quickly turned into a much more broad discussion about copyright and fan ethics. I'm considering writing a full post on it, as a lot of the ideas that they brought up were really very enlightening.

Right after that, I had to rush to my Greg Ayres interview, only to be held up by a string of staff confusions and rescheduling that resulted in at least 45 minutes of idle time. Nevertheless, once the valiant Press Relations guy Jamison got Greg into the room with me, we had a great interview, talking over his views on the current state of fansubs and the industry.

After a trip to the oddly empty Dealer's Room with Anime World Order's Daryl Surat, I headed to Experts of Fan Controversy, which looked like it was going to be a fiery debate between some of the smartest minds in the industry, moderated by panelist extraordinaire Alex Leavitt. Instead it ended up being a totally respectful, insightful discussion between the panelists (which included AnimeOnDVD's Chris Beveridge, Vertical's Ed Chavez, MIT's Jennifer Fuu, Anime World Order's Clarissa Graffeo, and Tezuka In English's Ada Palmer), punctuated by some funny moments and Alex's wacky scoring system. I recorded the panel in its entirety, so you might hear that in podcast form very soon.

Then... not much, con-wise. We had a sort of "State of the Manga Industry" dinner that ended up being more of an informal night at a local Indian restaurant, and I was denied entry (again) to Daryl's "Anime's Craziest Deaths" panel since it was already jam-packed. (I'll save my full-length misgivings about this situation for the con report.)

Finally, I ended up just bouncing around to a couple of video rooms, settling on Golgo 13 TV, where I met two teenage girls who were loving the show. I recommended they check out the 1983 movie, the OAV, and the manga (and pointed out that most of them are available in the Dealer's Room at the con). It was one of the stand-out moments of my day — they seemed so excited, filled with the kind of exploratory attitude that we need more of as a fandom. Plus, who would've thought that teenage girls would be enjoying Golgo 13 that much? The show is for Japanese salarymen!



Click here for more of our Anime Boston 2011 coverage

Back to Boston! [EDIT 1]

Topics:
Anime Boston 2011

True Story: Despite living in New Jersey for my entire life, the first anime convention I ever attended was actually Anime Boston, and since attending in 2005 or so, I have never been back to the large con. This year, however, is different.

I'm heading up from Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute with the school's Science-Fiction Association, which is organizing a trip to the con. While up in Boston, I will be blogging about the convention's myriad panels and events and maybe grabbing an interview or two with the guests. Plus, I will co-presenting with Daryl Surat of Anime World Order on his "Remembering Satoshi Kon" panel. (I ran a similar one at Genericon, and I hope to bring my own insights to what is already looking to be a great panel about the late director's life and work.)

As usual, I've included my tentative schedule — complete with overlaps that I will reconcile on the fly at the con — after the break. Note the number of Charles Dunbar panels; after Ink's great write-up and my own repeated failure to attend his panels, I'm going to make a real effort to see them this time.

Are you going to the con? What events are you looking forward to?

EDIT 1: Modified my list a little after realizing that I missed a few panels.




Friday
When What Where
10–11 am Who Was Carl Macek? Panel 309
11 am-12 pm Oda Nobunaga: Evil Sorceror or Space Alien? Panel A
1–2:45 pm The Tokyo "Nonexistant Youth" Bill and How It Affects You Panel 309
3–4 pm Castles, Forests and Bath Houses: The Worlds of Hayao Miyazaki Panel A
3:30–4:30 pm Future of the Fullmetal Fandom: Is It Really Over!? Panel 306
4–5 pm Anime Intro & Ending Themes Panel 302/304
6–7:30 pm Experts of Fan Controversy Panel 107
6–7 pm Dubs That Time Forgot Panel 202
7–8:30 pm Totally Subversive Toons Panel 309
8:30–9:30 pm Villains and Virgins: The Madonna-Heathen Complex in Anime Panel 107
8:30–9:30 pm I <3 the 90's Panel 306
9:30–11:30 pm Anime's Craziest Deaths Panel 306

Saturday
When What Where
10–11 am The Family That Geeks Together, Keeps Together Panel 107
11 am–12 pm Tezuka 101 Panel 206
12–1 pm It's a Rumic World Panel 309
1–2 pm State of the Industry Panel 306
2–3 pm Sentai Filmworks Panel 306
3:30–4:30 pm Remembering Satoshi Kon (1963-2010) Panel 202
5–6 pm Notable Directors of Anime That Aren't Hayao Miyazaki Panel 309
6–7 pm "What is Super-Flat": Where Anime fits in Post-Modern Culture Panel 206
7–8 pm Omoide In My Head: A Brief Guide to Japanese Indie Rock Panel 202
7–9 pm Bad Anime, Bad!! Panel A
8–9 pm Dead Like Us: Shinigami, Death Lore and Japanese Media Panel 107
8–9 pm Animating Music in Anime About Music Panel 206
11 pm–12 am STEREOPONY Concert Auditorium

Sunday
When What Where
10–11 am The Visions of Akira Kurosawa Panel 202
12–1 pm Spirits, Wheel and Borrowed Gods: Religion in Japan Panel 202
12–1 pm Satoshi Kon RIP (this is NOT Daryl's panel) Panel 302/304
12–1 pm From East to West: the Superheroes of Japan & America Panel A
1–2:30 pm An International Game of Telephone: The Japanese Culture Exchange Panel 107